Zak Yudhishthu
@zyudhishthu.bsky.social
3.7K followers 1.1K following 1.3K posts
Sidewalk enthusiast and former St. Paulite. I like to write about housing policy, especially in the Twin Cities. Nowadays I’m an economics research assistant in Chicago https://pencillingout.substack.com/
Posts Media Videos Starter Packs
Pinned
zyudhishthu.bsky.social
From 2010-2020, North Center was the Chicago neighborhood with the fastest growth in children. But surprisingly, its housing stock actually declined over that period!

In my new post, I take a look at Chicago's hottest neighborhood for families and think about some important housing dynamics.
Family growth, deconversions and housing supply in North Center
What we can learn from Chicago's hottest neighborhood for families
pencillingout.substack.com
zyudhishthu.bsky.social
Okay heres an interesting mention of that exact purpose in this @zachmortice.bsky.social story on Worker’s Cottages
www.bloomberg.com/news/feature...
zyudhishthu.bsky.social
I’m not totally sure, the book doesn’t have much to say about that
zyudhishthu.bsky.social
Meanwhile here’s what the block looks like today. Still some original cottages it looks like?
zyudhishthu.bsky.social
An 1889 ad for newly-built workers’ cottages in McKinley Park: “for the price, the handsomest, best-built brick cottages in the City.”
Reposted by Zak Yudhishthu
leniann.bsky.social
This is Berwyn, my red line station ❤️
Imagine instead of this city block wide jewel parking lot, we instead see more storefronts with entrances facing the sidewalk and housing built on top
Strip mall in background. Jewel parking lot. Berwyn red line station in foreground
zyudhishthu.bsky.social
Haha, this is the only positive response I’ve seen so far. I definitely think this is a waaaay under recognized point.
zyudhishthu.bsky.social
Agree with that!

I feel like they’d start with a Lyft scooter-style seasonal approach, taking the fleet off the road once it snows
zyudhishthu.bsky.social
Plus, co-chairs of the House transportation committee have signaled openness to the idea
zyudhishthu.bsky.social
Well, here it comes: @toreyvanoot.bsky.social reports that Waymo has hired lobbyists in Minnesota and been talking to state lawmakers, looking for legislative approval to operate in MN

www.axios.com/local/twin-c...
Reposted by Zak Yudhishthu
stephenjacobsmith.com
I can't stop thinking about this. We're pursuing zero fire risk in multifam, while tolerating much more in single-fam. People respond by building and living in single-fam, where they're exposed to not only one of the highest fire death risks in the developed world, but also TONS more car crash risk
ebwhamilton.bsky.social
Love this new report on buildings' relative fire safety from @alexhrwtz.bsky.social and Pew colleagues.

www.pew.org/en/research-...
zyudhishthu.bsky.social
I always called it “the Brooklyn of Saint Paul”
Reposted by Zak Yudhishthu
andersem.bsky.social
IMO @zyudhishthu.bsky.social nails it on mandatory minimum densities: you CAN do them right, but the benefits are so minimal & the risks so inevitable that they're not worth the trouble pencillingout.substack.com/p/can-we-boo...
In Minneapolis’s downtown, development must be 10 stories tall with a 4.0 FAR, while different transit-adjacent areas have minimum heights ranging from 2 to 10 stories.

This policy has come into play a couple of times in the past few years. For example, in 2023, a developer wanted to build a seven-story, 135-unit building next to Minneapolis’s Prospect Park Green Line stop. However, the lot was zoned for a 10-story height minimum and city staff refused to grant a variance for a seven-story building. The development was rejected, and no new construction has occurred on the lot.
zyudhishthu.bsky.social
Imagine waking up from a coma, out cold since 2016, to learn that “the governor of California is giving a non-response about statewide upzoning on a Fortnite stream”
metamodernism.bsky.social
It’s funny how after several days of people nervously posting about whether or not Newsom will sign SB 79, the best insight we’ve gotten is from Gavin himself on a Fortnite stream
zyudhishthu.bsky.social
Well I absolutely agree with that!

It sucks that SFHs can outbid a three flat, but the deck is stacked. And honestly, those SFH purchasers should be forced to compete not just with 3-flats but with far denser development (ie should upzone much more)
zyudhishthu.bsky.social
I was gonna post about that but I think that instance is the best counterexample to my argument! That’s really crazy and I get why it angers people. It’s also an extreme case in a pretty particular neighborhood.

But ultimately I think that zoning broadly for more density is a lot more important
zyudhishthu.bsky.social
At the end of the day, housing markets are complex things, and I’m hesitant about the role of prescriptive regulatory policy in successfully tackling our problems. Reasonable urbanists could disagree, but beware the pitfalls of using zoning to restrict less-dense development.
zyudhishthu.bsky.social
Even w/o harming development, someone is worse off with these policies. Eg. deconversions in Chicago’s North side seem to supporting strong growth in the number of families.

Affected households are likely richer, so the tradeoff might be worth it. But the tradeoff does exist.
zyudhishthu.bsky.social
But I’m not sure how easy it is to pull off this strategy without accidentally hurting development. In Minneapolis, a 10-story height minimum led to no development at all after rejecting 7 stories. Store owners rebuilding after 2020 are struggling to meet 2-story minimums!
zyudhishthu.bsky.social
What does this strategy accomplish? In some places, people with a lot of willingness (and ability) to pay for certain housing, like a SFH, can outbid a denser development that is otherwise feasible. Zoning for minimum density can box these people out, getting to more density.
zyudhishthu.bsky.social
Or see Portland’s 2020 zoning reforms: the city implemented a FAR limit where none had been before, seeking to zone out “McMansions”. In exchange, the FAR gets larger with more units, so 4plexes can be larger than a SFH.

The explicit goal is to (dis)favor certain housing types
zyudhishthu.bsky.social
As another example of this policy, Minneapolis’ 2040 Plan also implemented minimum FAR and buildings heights in various districts of the city, explicitly zoning out development that they don’t thing is dense enough.