Mattathias Schwartz
@schwartzesque.bsky.social
1.4K followers 400 following 250 posts
legal affairs correspondent // The New York Times first dot last at n y times dot com
Posts Media Videos Starter Packs
Reposted by Mattathias Schwartz
nytimes.com
More than three dozen federal judges have told The New York Times that the Supreme Court’s flurry of brief, opaque emergency orders in cases related to the Trump administration have left them confused about how to proceed in those matters and are hurting the judiciary’s image with the public.
Federal Judges, Warning of ‘Judicial Crisis,’ Fault Supreme Court’s Emergency Orders
Dozens of sitting judges shared with The Times their concerns about risks to the courts’ legitimacy as the Supreme Court releases opaque orders about Trump administration policies.
nyti.ms
Reposted by Mattathias Schwartz
charlesornstein.bsky.social
Sixty-five judges responded to a @nytimes.com questionnaire sent to hundreds of federal judges across the country. Of those, 47 said the Supreme Court had been mishandling its emergency docket since Mr. Trump returned to office.
Federal Judges, Warning of ‘Judicial Crisis,’ Fault Supreme Court’s Emergency Orders
www.nytimes.com
schwartzesque.bsky.social
I've been made aware of an interesting proposal to rebrand our planet as RTH
Reposted by Mattathias Schwartz
debpearlstein.bsky.social
Of all the news in this NYT survey of sitting federal judges - incl 47 of them think the SCt is mishandling its emergency docket - maybe the biggest is that 65 sitting fed judges (37D, 28R), folks circumspect for a living, responded to a NYT survey. Stunning. And a sign that something is very wrong.
Federal Judges, Warning of ‘Judicial Crisis,’ Fault Supreme Court’s Emergency Orders
www.nytimes.com
schwartzesque.bsky.social
NEW: We talked to 65 federal judges about the Supreme Court’s use of the emergency docket during Trump’s 2nd term, how it impacts morale in the lower courts, and its effect on the public’s view of the judiciary.

They had a lot to say.

Free gift link … www.nytimes.com/2025/10/11/u...
Federal Judges, Warning of ‘Judicial Crisis,’ Fault Supreme Court’s Emergency Orders
www.nytimes.com
Reposted by Mattathias Schwartz
leahlitman.bsky.social
More judges speak to the press (the NYT) about what a disaster the Supreme Court (specifically the shadow docket) has been - “incredibly demoralizing & troubling”; a “judicial crisis”; a “slap in the face to district courts.” www.nytimes.com/2025/10/11/u...
Excerpts Excerpts
schwartzesque.bsky.social
NEW: “The significance of the public’s interest in having only well-trained LE officers deployed in their communities and avoiding unnecessary shows of military force in their neighborhoods cannot be overstated."

Our story on Judge Perry's ruling, free gift link >> www.nytimes.com/2025/10/10/u...
schwartzesque.bsky.social
JUST IN -- Judge April Perry finds that "that deployment of National Guard members is likely to lead to civil unrest"

full opinion on yesterday's TRO here >>> storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.us...
schwartzesque.bsky.social
seems like we may have reached Peak News
Reposted by Mattathias Schwartz
haleaziz.bsky.social
On Sept. 27, President Trump described Portland, Ore., as a “War ravaged” city.

But here is how federal officers described the scene outside the ICE building in southwest Portland on Sept. 25: “low energy.”

The next day the same: “low energy.”

www.nytimes.com/2025/10/08/u...
Before Trump Ordered In Troops, Federal Officers Called Portland Protests ‘Low Energy’
www.nytimes.com
Reposted by Mattathias Schwartz
samfellman.bsky.social
This op-ed by Thomas Edsall referenced my reporting on the anti-woke activists targeting military officers: www.nytimes.com/2025/10/07/o...
Opinion | Trump Is Not Afraid of Civil War. Neither Is Stephen Miller.
www.nytimes.com
schwartzesque.bsky.social
I spoke with The Daily about the judiciary's response to Trump's attempt to deploy the National Guard into US cities, and the question of whether simply declaring a "rebellion" makes it so, for legal purposes: www.nytimes.com/2025/10/08/p...
Trump Claims ‘Rebellion’ in American Cities
www.nytimes.com
schwartzesque.bsky.social
parents
dieworkwear.bsky.social
we need a word for a type of person who spends all their time working to live in a city so they can be near cool things, but they don't actually like going out
Reposted by Mattathias Schwartz
Reposted by Mattathias Schwartz
yearprogress.bsky.social
▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓░░░░░ 75.82%
Reposted by Mattathias Schwartz
srubenfeld.bsky.social
Two teens at the community garden tried on suit jackets from the adjoining free store.

Faking like they had a microphone, one said to the other: “I’d like to talk to you about tax evasion.”
Reposted by Mattathias Schwartz
charliesavage.bsky.social
I experienced this last week & refused, saying I had never before been asked to provide the names of any analysts I was planning to quote to get a comment. Spox replied that maybe they were D donors. (In that case, it was 3 retired top military JAG officers.) I guess that was not a weird oneoff.
shannonbond.bsky.social
we wrote about this WH tactic recently. they’re asking journalists for expert source names and then using them to look up political donations in FEC records to try to discredit those sources as biased.

www.npr.org/2025/08/18/n...
amykristinsanders.bsky.social
I had this exact same experience this morning. Same reporter as Heidi.

This is *not* normal.

I have spoken to the press on these issues for two decades. No government official has ever demanded to know my identity in order to give a comment on a story.
Reposted by Mattathias Schwartz
zjmontague.bsky.social
Judge Timothy Kelly blocks the Trump administration from carrying out any removals of Guatemalan children, writing pretty sternly that all of its claims about reunifying them with their families at their parents’ request turned out to be false, and cover for a rushed “midnight operation.”
Judge Blocks Administration From Immediately Removing Guatemalan Children
www.nytimes.com
schwartzesque.bsky.social
The First Amendment is a radical libertarian grant. Something of an anomaly globally. It’s a challenging thing to maintain. Has always been and will always be subject to intense dispute and reinterpretation, especially at the margin
Reposted by Mattathias Schwartz
aric.bsky.social
The Utah shooter joked on Discord with his friends that his doppelganger killed Charlie Kirk when they asked him about it

From Nick Bogel-Burroughs, and contribution from me.
www.nytimes.com/2025/09/13/u...
Reposted by Mattathias Schwartz
ewong.bsky.social
NEW: Sec. Marco Rubio casts himself as a top general in Trump's new war in Latin America. He has steered the administration toward military strikes on drug traffickers, without due process. One killed 11 people. And he pushes mass deportations. Our story: www.nytimes.com/2025/09/12/u...
Rubio Leads Charge in Trump’s New War in Latin America
www.nytimes.com