Baby Boy Monaghan
@babyboymonaghan.bsky.social
2.8K followers 560 following 11K posts
Arts editor for MPR as Max Sparber. Award-winning cultural critic & Jewish Studies writer. 3X illegitimate. He/him.
Posts Media Videos Starter Packs
babyboymonaghan.bsky.social
But you’re really tipping your hat with this “delusional victimhood” talk.
babyboymonaghan.bsky.social
Christian Zionism predates and vastly outnumbers Jewish Zionism
babyboymonaghan.bsky.social
If you're not Jewish, you're not part of the "we" that makes any decisions here
babyboymonaghan.bsky.social
It's a pretty good Kinks song too
babyboymonaghan.bsky.social
You literally responded to them
babyboymonaghan.bsky.social
No, it predates antisemitism, however, it is a classic (perhaps the classic) example of anti-Judaism in the Gospels, and almost certainly never happened
babyboymonaghan.bsky.social
the Mongo Santamaría version is also stunning
babyboymonaghan.bsky.social
I don’t know how to tell you that you can’t copyright an image made by ChatGPT
babyboymonaghan.bsky.social
Crypt Keeper: Now to sit down with a good book, Anne of SCREAM Gables. (Flipping through book.) I have badly misunderstood the title of this book.
babyboymonaghan.bsky.social
The Gemara asks if Moses was ever mistaken. Rabbi Eliezer ben Hyrcanus answers that Moses once supposed his noses was roses. What does this mean? Rabbi Yehoshua ben Ḥananya answers that when that happened, Moses supposed erroneously.
babyboymonaghan.bsky.social
Me: I’m sapiosexual.

You: Ah, attracted to smart people.

Me: (putting a tap in a maple tree in full bondage gear) What?
babyboymonaghan.bsky.social
Ent (476) seeks partner for long, very slow conversations
babyboymonaghan.bsky.social
I'm guessing he'd claim it to be true, even though the writer was Irish-American
babyboymonaghan.bsky.social
One thing is absolutely Jewison's fault -- he found Zero Mostel too American, too broad, which is why he cast Topol, who he saw as somehow more universal.

Not a Jew alive sees Mostel as anything other than somebody who rolled off the Yiddish stage and into movies.
babyboymonaghan.bsky.social
Tevye talks about poverty, but he seems to be doing ... okay. The grinding poverty in the stories is absent. Tevye's cow shows up late in the stories, a reward for saving two women, and basically moves him up an entire class.
babyboymonaghan.bsky.social
Anyway, there are some places where I think he poorly represented European Judaism, but I don't know if it's his fault or Robbins.

It does not capture the extent to which Orthodox Jewish life then was bounded by prayer and ritual
babyboymonaghan.bsky.social
Also I'm not sure what was percolating in Jerome Robbins and Tommy Abbott's brains, but the expressionistic poses of the film's fiddler feel like a fever-dream of Jewish movement.
babyboymonaghan.bsky.social
I don't think the film's folk art shul (with a scorpion painting!) or bottle dance are period accurate, but damn, they're awesome. A lot of American Jews, knowing very little about their actual European history, basically filled in the blanks with Fiddler, and I ask -- why not this?
babyboymonaghan.bsky.social
I watched the documentary about the making of Fiddler and while Norman Jewison (despite his name, not-Jewish) constantly declaring himself an honorary Jew does get a little much, maybe he deserves it?
babyboymonaghan.bsky.social
Merkabah originates from the Semitic roots r-k-b, meaning to ride. And unless you're pushing using mystical tools to visit the various Jewish heavens, we Jews already have Merkabah and it's not on the market for weirdo new age appropriators.
babyboymonaghan.bsky.social
Dracula is actually about an unhinged English cult poisoning themselves with untyped blood transfusions and blaming the immigrant next door
rachelfeder.bsky.social
Tell me your most unhinged literary opinion, as a little treat