I remember that game blowing my mind when I first played it at a sleepover. I was a kid and I stayed up hours after my friend went to sleep, playing it on his dad's Xbox all night long while the whole house was asleep

I feel like Dishonored and Mirror's Edge deserve honorable mentions. Star Wars: The Force Unleashed too, perhaps

This blows my mind!!! I'm like how do I know not to put white out in my can and I've never set foot in a forge!!!

Every season, they make Canister Damascus (Google it) with white out—something that elicits audible groans from the judges literally every time, and pretty much always leads to disaster. Arrogance is a big part of it, of course. Many of the losers puff themselves up in their intro bios.
3/9

Ugh that is so annoying

Wow

Any idea when in the show's run this poll was conducted?