Richard Shaw
richardshaw.bsky.social
Richard Shaw
@richardshaw.bsky.social

Researcher @ University of Glasgow, UK. Epidemiologist interested in mental-health and wellbeing, health inequalities, administrative data, education.

Trying to learn Italian and Spanish.

Public Health 35%
Psychology 21%

Reposted by Richard Shaw

"An old saying about such follies is that “six months in the lab can you save you an afternoon in the library”; here we may have wasted a trillion dollars and several years to rediscover what cognitive science already knew."

garymarcus.substack.com/p/a-trillion...
A trillion dollars is a terrible thing to waste
The machine learning community is finally waking up to the madness, but the detour of the last few years has been costly.
garymarcus.substack.com

Senior academics arguing cover authorship is also a red flag. 2nd worst project I worked on, two of the CIs spent an hour and half shouting at each other over authorship of papers that weren't written yet.

Papers were never published as the CIs could no longer work with each other.

Biggest problem with authorship is that far too many papers are being churned out to enhance people's careers with little scientific merit.

It's much easier for an ECR to be first author in medical sciences than social sciences, where a lot of PIs block people's chances to write papers so they can be first author on everything.

It's a problem with all journalism on all topics. The worst was the coverage of Miliband's leadership of the leader party. Every fall in opinion polls was headline news, the rises were ignored.

It's helps stop senior PIs taking the credit from ECRs who write the papers and do most of the work.

The ability to say "No" strategically requires a degree of job security and power that most early career researchers lack.

The real issue is that some senior academics exploit this ruthlessly. What is needed better management focused on supporting the whole community.

It's not just about algorithms. For a period (Up until 2015?) the Twitter community did quite a lot of work to promote different voices and strengthen networks for everybody.

The migration to bsky enabled those with high number of followers to keep them, but, the wider community building is absent.

It's officially the "High Value Council Tax Surcharge". It's called a "Mansion Tax" precisely because that is a more acceptable term for "most people".

Of course "most people" might in reality be the very wealthy newspaper owners who don't want a serious discussion about wealth inequality.

This is why the country is completely screwed.

Junior ex minister booted out of office and gets a nice cosy position in a Quango thanks to their political connections. They can then leverage that position to get a hole host of related roles.

Meanwhile actual experts struggle to find work.

This may annoy me more than anything today's budget.

If the UK was serious about Health Data Science they might actually might employ somebody with expertise in the area. Instead they appoint a failed politician with a degree in music.

It's even more absurd because she is Tory.

I don't think it is just an issue of miscommunication.

Conceptualising population as opposed to individual level effects requires high level abstract thinking. Thus while a academic's work might reflect population scale thinking, outside work people often confuse the two even in though own area.
One of the biggest challenges in public health & environment-related fields is the miscommunication of population-scale results to the individual-level

This is often caused by the desire to formulate “action” relevant to people’s lives but ends up blaming individuals for things not in their control
Important new report out on precarious working conditions in Geography in UK HE. Sadly the nature and scale of the findings are grim but unsurprising. www.rgs.org/research/hig...
States of precarity in UK Higher Education geography
Findings from a discipline-focused research project exploring the lived realities of precarious academic work within UK Higher Education geography.
www.rgs.org

Reposted by Richard Shaw

⚠️ Closing tomorrow!

We're hiring a Senior Quantitative Researcher!

Can you turn data into creative, high-quality analysis and visualisation?

Experienced with applied quantitative methods and national survey datasets?

We'd love to hear from you.

Don't miss out - apply now 🔽

bit.ly/3LqTdzQ
Octo Candidates - Application Form - Vacancy Details
bit.ly

Don't you think that the person's avatar, Dr Stranglove, a satirical Nazi war criminal who starts a nuclear war, might be a bit of clue to the degree of insanity?

Can somebody explain to me why a person whose avatar is Dr Strangelove is being taken seriously?

How more obvious can trolling be than a satirical Nazi war criminal who starts a nuclear war?

The world has enough problems without people putting trolls on pedestals only so they can be knocked down.
One way to take some of the heat out of politics, which is within the BBC's control, is to drop phone-ins and vox pops.

Reposted by Richard Shaw

Arguments for why social care isn't just for older people, a thread.

A lot of details would need to be worked out, such as editors red flagging people doing superficial reviews.

It wouldn't be impossible to create a central database enabling journals to require people's publication metrics be more in equilibrium with their review metrics before they are allowed to submit more than a couple of papers.

Many of my research colleagues over the years have taken early retirement due to their contracts ending. Retirement is much more attractive than having to compete in a hyper-competitive labour market rife with ageism.

Stop making people redundant if you want them to say in work.

Reposted by Richard Shaw

Half of UK workers aged 50–65 leave work before retirement. How can we change that?

Join FPH, SOM & Centre for Ageing Better for an online webinar on enabling older workers to stay and return to work.

Find out more and register www.fph.org.uk/events-cours...
Enabling older workers to stay and return to work – Society of Occupational Medicine supported by the Centre for Ageing Better
The UK Economy needs older workers, yet half the workforce aged 50-65 leave before retirement. Current local delivery of programmes to reduce inactivity due to ill health often ignores this key group,...
www.fph.org.uk

Unfortunately, deciding what a person wants to say and then manipulating evidence to fit seems to be the default position in most areas of life not just the BBC. This includes politics, journalism and academia. See the work on Questionable Research practices ukrio.org/ukrio-resour...
Questionable Research Practices - UK Research Integrity Office
Guidance from UKRIO Simon Kolstoe. Defining the Spectrum of Questionable Research Practices (QRPs), UKRIO, 2023 https://doi.org/10.37672/UKRIO.2023.02.QRPs References Andrade C. (2021). HARKing, Cherr...
ukrio.org
Quick thread on the BBC and the political and societal significance of recent developments:

One of the main reasons the UK has historically been so much less polarised than the US, is that Britain has a shared source of information, consumed and trusted by most people regardless of their politics.

May be accepting Jeremy Hunt's tax cuts and promising not to put up Income Tax and VAT was in the long run a very bad idea.
After Liz Truss's mini-budget, just 15 per cent of people felt the Tories were the best party at handling the economy

Today, the equivalent figure for Labour is 12 per cent

www.thetimes.com/article/470f...
The impossible dream some people on the British right are chasing is that you can have a BBC News operation that retreats from detail and expertise, that takes dictation from the government, but this will only create incompetence and failure when it suits you:
To fix the BBC, focus on competence and cash
Corporation fails to learn from criticism, while politicians have consciously reduced its scope for quality journalism
www.ft.com

I think this is true of academia in general. Institutional knowledge of how the system operates is far more important for careers than disciplinary specific knowledge.
We’ve forgotten what universities are for
We’ve forgotten what universities are for
With New Zealand universities facing not only a funding crisis but a philosophical challenge to their role, the soul of tertiary education is at stake....
thespinoff.co.nz

Reposted by Richard Shaw

After Liz Truss's mini-budget, just 15 per cent of people felt the Tories were the best party at handling the economy

Today, the equivalent figure for Labour is 12 per cent

www.thetimes.com/article/470f...