As the holidays inspire reflection and generosity, we’re asking: Does the Effective Altruism Movement Get Giving Right? This debate dives into the ethics and impact of how we give, sparking thoughtful conversations with family and friends. Watch here: https://bit.ly/4pqgaSg

The U.S. is launching military strikes against cartels, deploying warships, and reshaping foreign policy in real time. Is this a necessary response to a growing threat—or a dangerous step toward endless conflict? Watch the debate now. https://youtu.be/1UVYAs9sDE0

Today's special bonus podcast episode features our founder, Robert Rosenkranz, in conversation with Spencer Greenberg of the Clearer Thinking Podcast. Listen now: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/bonus-why-debate-matters-robert-rosenkranz-on-clearer/id216713308?i=1000737389670

Which generation is the most screwed? Watch journalists representing Gen X, Gen Z, and Baby Boomers debate this charged topic.

Should everyone get Social Security if they don’t need it?

America’s Social Security clash comes into sharp focus in this exchange: one side argues the system can only survive by expanding the workforce, while another says benefits shouldn’t go to wealthy retirees who don’t need them.

"Make America like France again?"

Ending birthright citizenship sounds simple — until you ask what hospitals, parents, and even families with uncertain paternity are supposed to do. Should the U.S. follow countries like France and Australia, or stand by its founding promise?

If parents come to America seeking opportunity and give birth, should their children be denied citizenship — or is that the very promise of being American?

Featuring @cnewman.bsky.social, @markskrikorian.bsky.social, Horace Cooper, and @azagmayes.bsky.social.

Watch the full debate on YouTube.

Should birthright citizenship remain an unshakable American right—or is it time to reconsider who’s entitled to it?

This debate was produced in partnership between Open to Debate, ASU’s Institute of Politics, and Arizona PBS as part of the PRO/CONversations series.

Watch: https://bit.ly/3Jf1C8Q

Why are women still excluded from being ordained Catholic Deacons?

Casey Stanton says it’s becoming “untenable” to worship where women’s voices aren’t heard — but Pia de Solenni, argues Jesus “knew what he was doing” and calls for going deeper. Watch the debate now. https://youtu.be/tIywKOgWRrs

In a world without a “global police,” is war just human nature—or a choice we keep making?

Dylan Motin argues that power and survival drive nations to fight. Gabrielle Rifkind counters: war isn’t inevitable—it’s a failure we choose.

Watch the debate now. https://youtu.be/8SdiPACjsCQ

Israel and Hamas have agreed on the first phase of a peace plan which could potentially put an end to the two-year war. But will peace take root after generations of violence?

Are we losing humanity by letting AI make life-and-death decisions? Or could AI weapons actually reduce harm by acting without fear, anger, or revenge?

Featuring: Laura Walker McDonald of @icrc.org & Michael C. Horowitz of @perryworldhouse.bsky.social