Well, it’s a strange hobby…

As you say, a bit hard to judge from the pics, but the warmer buff tone on and below the ear coverts looks good for tristis

We like your colour scheme

But conservation action of various kinds is likely the main driver behind UK increases of at least 3 of the 5 large wading birds (Crane, Bittern, Spoonbill) reported in record numbers in 2023. It is possible to celebrate these recoveries as genuinely good news.

Of course I’m not denying that climate is involved in northward spread, or a threat to cold adapted species including breeders e.g. Slavonian Grebe as well as winterers. I share your concern regarding the impact of climate change.

I’m seriously telling you the evidence for Spoonbill is that conservation action has enabled recovery into the historical range. Based on the literature reviewing the recovery. But maybe you know better 🤷‍♂️

Ledger et al. (2022) p158-161 www.rewildingeurope.com/wp-content/u... & Keller et al. (2020) attribute the recovery to habitat protection, management and creation, pesticide bans and hunting control. Not climate (that’s recognised as a threat). The increase in the UK is recovery of historical range.

Somehow missed this before. Well done Julian, richly deserved!