I made a celebration image with fountain pens thanks to @johndodd.bsky.social
I made a celebration image with fountain pens thanks to @johndodd.bsky.social
The feeling you get when something is stolen from you is a strange one to be sure, but when you know who done it...
Well...
www.thedodd.com/post/the-gre...
The feeling you get when something is stolen from you is a strange one to be sure, but when you know who done it...
Well...
www.thedodd.com/post/the-gre...
52. What other developments are driving emerging questions for the UK’s copyright framework, and how should the government respond to them?
Too many to list here, but they should be responded to in honest consultation
52. What other developments are driving emerging questions for the UK’s copyright framework, and how should the government respond to them?
Too many to list here, but they should be responded to in honest consultation
51. What are the implications of the use of synthetic data to train AI models and how could this develop over time, and how should the government respond?
51. What are the implications of the use of synthetic data to train AI models and how could this develop over time, and how should the government respond?
50. Is the legal framework that applies to AI products that interact with copyright works at the point of inference clear? If it is not, what could the government do to make it clearer?
Yes No
50. Is the legal framework that applies to AI products that interact with copyright works at the point of inference clear? If it is not, what could the government do to make it clearer?
Yes No
None of it is positive...
None of it is positive...
Not at all
Not at all
Just for reference here, the EU’s approach requires that all output be labelled appropriately, if it had an AI in its creation, it should be labelled as such, and be machine readable as such.
Just for reference here, the EU’s approach requires that all output be labelled appropriately, if it had an AI in its creation, it should be labelled as such, and be machine readable as such.
46. How can government support development of emerging tools and standards, reflecting the technical challenges associated with labelling tools?
Be clear about them, see statement above
46. How can government support development of emerging tools and standards, reflecting the technical challenges associated with labelling tools?
Be clear about them, see statement above
45. Do you agree that generative AI outputs should be labelled as AI generated? If so, what is a proportionate approach, and is regulation required?
Yes No
Yes
45. Do you agree that generative AI outputs should be labelled as AI generated? If so, what is a proportionate approach, and is regulation required?
Yes No
Yes
44. What steps should AI providers take to avoid copyright infringing outputs?
Full list of all material used in their data capture process
44. What steps should AI providers take to avoid copyright infringing outputs?
Full list of all material used in their data capture process
43. Does the current approach to liability in AI-generated outputs allow effective enforcement of copyright?
Multiple choice yes/no – Selected No
43. Does the current approach to liability in AI-generated outputs allow effective enforcement of copyright?
Multiple choice yes/no – Selected No
42. Would the removal of the current CGW provision affect you or your organisation? Please provide quantitative information where possible
Multiple choice - Significant positive effect Minor positive effect
42. Would the removal of the current CGW provision affect you or your organisation? Please provide quantitative information where possible
Multiple choice - Significant positive effect Minor positive effect
41. What would be the economic impact of doing this? Please provide quantitative information where possible.
Humans might make money off creative things again?
Thieves might not prosper
41. What would be the economic impact of doing this? Please provide quantitative information where possible.
Humans might make money off creative things again?
Thieves might not prosper
Yes/No leading into an answer box – Yes
Because they’re not original works done by a person who had to learn how to do them, rather an output from a machine that did all the work for them
Yes/No leading into an answer box – Yes
Because they’re not original works done by a person who had to learn how to do them, rather an output from a machine that did all the work for them
39. Would reforming the CGW provision have an impact on you or your organisation? If so, how? Please provide quantitative information where possible.
39. Would reforming the CGW provision have an impact on you or your organisation? If so, how? Please provide quantitative information where possible.
38. Should other changes be made to the scope of CGW protection?
Separate consultation that shouldn't be part of this right now
38. Should other changes be made to the scope of CGW protection?
Separate consultation that shouldn't be part of this right now
37. Would CGW legislation benefit from greater legal clarity, for example to clarify the originality requirement? If so, how should it be clarified?
Yes/No, but unlike question 19, also had the answer as part of the question, leading me to think
37. Would CGW legislation benefit from greater legal clarity, for example to clarify the originality requirement? If so, how should it be clarified?
Yes/No, but unlike question 19, also had the answer as part of the question, leading me to think
36. Do you have views on how the provision should be interpreted?
As stated, it says that machine generated works are protected because the AI has no incentive towards money, thereby conveniently sidestepping the humans behind it.
36. Do you have views on how the provision should be interpreted?
As stated, it says that machine generated works are protected because the AI has no incentive towards money, thereby conveniently sidestepping the humans behind it.
35. Are you in favour of maintaining current protection for computer-generated works? If yes, please explain whether and how you currently rely on this provision.
I do not, and will not rely on this provision, all my works are human created.
35. Are you in favour of maintaining current protection for computer-generated works? If yes, please explain whether and how you currently rely on this provision.
I do not, and will not rely on this provision, all my works are human created.
The next two sections aren't questions, they're section D of www.gov.uk/government/c...
Which currently seems to say that AI generated things should have protection
The next two sections aren't questions, they're section D of www.gov.uk/government/c...
Which currently seems to say that AI generated things should have protection