"Online Rent-a-Sage" Bret Devereaux
@bretdevereaux.bsky.social
Ancient & military historian specializing in the Roman economy and military. PhD from UNC History. More impressive credential is that I have beaten both Dark Souls and Elden Ring.
Blogs at acoup.blog
Blogs at acoup.blog
Many people construct dream versions of foreign countries in their imagination, but Rod Dreher is the only person I have seen do so *while living there* for years.
November 11, 2025 at 6:51 PM
Many people construct dream versions of foreign countries in their imagination, but Rod Dreher is the only person I have seen do so *while living there* for years.
It's amazing anyone ever took this guy seriously - in interviews and his own writing he shows an astonishing ignorance of how Hungary even works (e.g. www.thebulwark.com/p/lashing-ou...).
Lashing Out, Rod Dreher (Again) Reveals His Ignorance of Hungary
A Louisiana blogger in Viktor Orbán’s court.
www.thebulwark.com
November 11, 2025 at 6:50 PM
It's amazing anyone ever took this guy seriously - in interviews and his own writing he shows an astonishing ignorance of how Hungary even works (e.g. www.thebulwark.com/p/lashing-ou...).
Uh, so this not being a double-legionary marching camp, I may be out of my element, but my first thought is that $500m seems like a kinda low figure for standing up a base of that size in that region?
November 11, 2025 at 6:44 PM
Uh, so this not being a double-legionary marching camp, I may be out of my element, but my first thought is that $500m seems like a kinda low figure for standing up a base of that size in that region?
A possibility I had considered: bsky.app/profile/bret...
Of course what you can tell is that Musk hasn't engaged with the actual poem, he's engaged with school-boy summaries of Trojan War mythology, so he's thinking about Paris and Helen (neither really central characters in the Iliad) and/or the movie adaptations.
November 11, 2025 at 5:33 AM
A possibility I had considered: bsky.app/profile/bret...
Also, see something like Troy (2004) for a, uh, very different take on the Briseis-Achilles relationship.
November 11, 2025 at 2:30 AM
Also, see something like Troy (2004) for a, uh, very different take on the Briseis-Achilles relationship.
This clearly shouldn't be my first response, but I just find myself so remarkably annoyed not by the fact that my field is being co-opted by the worst people, but that it is being co-opted by the dumbest people, just the thickest, most arrogantly superficial 'trousered apes' imaginable.
November 11, 2025 at 2:29 AM
This clearly shouldn't be my first response, but I just find myself so remarkably annoyed not by the fact that my field is being co-opted by the worst people, but that it is being co-opted by the dumbest people, just the thickest, most arrogantly superficial 'trousered apes' imaginable.
Oh, so a poem about Jason, late in life?
November 11, 2025 at 2:26 AM
Oh, so a poem about Jason, late in life?
Things we were typing at exactly the same time!
Yes, I think you are exactly right.
bsky.app/profile/bret...
Yes, I think you are exactly right.
bsky.app/profile/bret...
Of course what you can tell is that Musk hasn't engaged with the actual poem, he's engaged with school-boy summaries of Trojan War mythology, so he's thinking about Paris and Helen (neither really central characters in the Iliad) and/or the movie adaptations.
November 11, 2025 at 2:24 AM
Things we were typing at exactly the same time!
Yes, I think you are exactly right.
bsky.app/profile/bret...
Yes, I think you are exactly right.
bsky.app/profile/bret...
Of course what you can tell is that Musk hasn't engaged with the actual poem, he's engaged with school-boy summaries of Trojan War mythology, so he's thinking about Paris and Helen (neither really central characters in the Iliad) and/or the movie adaptations.
November 11, 2025 at 2:24 AM
Of course what you can tell is that Musk hasn't engaged with the actual poem, he's engaged with school-boy summaries of Trojan War mythology, so he's thinking about Paris and Helen (neither really central characters in the Iliad) and/or the movie adaptations.
Folks fixate on Achilles' book 9 descriptions of Briseis as like a wife to him that they miss how much that is obviously a pose and how Briseis herself instead (in bk 19) represents *Patroclus* as the one who was kind, not Achilles.
Achilles is at no point doing right by Briseis, nor trying to.
Achilles is at no point doing right by Briseis, nor trying to.
November 11, 2025 at 2:22 AM
Folks fixate on Achilles' book 9 descriptions of Briseis as like a wife to him that they miss how much that is obviously a pose and how Briseis herself instead (in bk 19) represents *Patroclus* as the one who was kind, not Achilles.
Achilles is at no point doing right by Briseis, nor trying to.
Achilles is at no point doing right by Briseis, nor trying to.
At least, that was what I was taught, I don't work directly on pre-history.
My understanding is that it is also generally accepted that India had its own pristine/primary states on the Indus, so not the same state tradition as Mesopotamia or Egypt.
My understanding is that it is also generally accepted that India had its own pristine/primary states on the Indus, so not the same state tradition as Mesopotamia or Egypt.
November 10, 2025 at 9:28 PM
At least, that was what I was taught, I don't work directly on pre-history.
My understanding is that it is also generally accepted that India had its own pristine/primary states on the Indus, so not the same state tradition as Mesopotamia or Egypt.
My understanding is that it is also generally accepted that India had its own pristine/primary states on the Indus, so not the same state tradition as Mesopotamia or Egypt.
Wheat and barley agriculture in India, while using the same plants, is generally thought to be an independent development, rather than an expansion of the Egyptian/Mesopotamian wheat farming tradition.
November 10, 2025 at 9:25 PM
Wheat and barley agriculture in India, while using the same plants, is generally thought to be an independent development, rather than an expansion of the Egyptian/Mesopotamian wheat farming tradition.
An online, updated, searchable form of the MRR would be a great digital classics project for someone to undertake, of course, but for now the PDFs serve well and honestly, including the corrigenda from 1960, there's not much new that's missing from the list.
November 10, 2025 at 9:00 PM
An online, updated, searchable form of the MRR would be a great digital classics project for someone to undertake, of course, but for now the PDFs serve well and honestly, including the corrigenda from 1960, there's not much new that's missing from the list.
Oh indeed and I am just noting the absurdity of that. If Classical Athens is the West, Byzantium must be as well, and the whole of the Roman Empire.
My complaint is with the arbitrary nature of these distinctions, which are mostly drawn to try to exclude less successful countries that belong.
My complaint is with the arbitrary nature of these distinctions, which are mostly drawn to try to exclude less successful countries that belong.
November 10, 2025 at 8:47 PM
Oh indeed and I am just noting the absurdity of that. If Classical Athens is the West, Byzantium must be as well, and the whole of the Roman Empire.
My complaint is with the arbitrary nature of these distinctions, which are mostly drawn to try to exclude less successful countries that belong.
My complaint is with the arbitrary nature of these distinctions, which are mostly drawn to try to exclude less successful countries that belong.
My only modification to this is I'd argue they played a bad hand...fine, I guess? Not good. Not badly.
The shutdown visibly damaged Trump and they've left the door open to doing it again a few months when (not if) they don't get their ACA compromise.
The shutdown visibly damaged Trump and they've left the door open to doing it again a few months when (not if) they don't get their ACA compromise.
November 10, 2025 at 8:31 PM
My only modification to this is I'd argue they played a bad hand...fine, I guess? Not good. Not badly.
The shutdown visibly damaged Trump and they've left the door open to doing it again a few months when (not if) they don't get their ACA compromise.
The shutdown visibly damaged Trump and they've left the door open to doing it again a few months when (not if) they don't get their ACA compromise.
Huh, that problem doesn't exist in its original context.
Wikipedia's maps copy-paste poorly, generally, I ought to have screenshotted.
Wikipedia's maps copy-paste poorly, generally, I ought to have screenshotted.
November 10, 2025 at 5:41 PM
Huh, that problem doesn't exist in its original context.
Wikipedia's maps copy-paste poorly, generally, I ought to have screenshotted.
Wikipedia's maps copy-paste poorly, generally, I ought to have screenshotted.