So it looks like in addition to the "this is not a PbtA game don't try to play it like a PbtA game" we're probably going to have to add "this is not Blades in the Dark don't play it like Blades in the Dark."

Do let us know what you think about Eureka's monsters and vampires if you check it out!

Yes this is a major theme in Eureka: Investigative Urban Fantasy. I don't have a lot of time today to get fully into it + bluesky character limit, but anyone can check it out in Chapter 6 here because it's free anim-ttrpg.itch.io/eureka-urban...

(though we kinda do need some more sales this month)

..gameplay experience this particular RPG was made to provide. They dont need your permission to change the rules, but if you did your job right (and didnt lie in your marketing) the rules wont need changing. You should tell them the rules confidently so that they wont feel they need to change them.

Kolchak: The Night Stalker was a huge inspiration for Eureka: Investigative Urban Fantasy.

When a character makes an attack against another character, you roll on a table for the effect it has on the target.