Satadru Pramanik
@satmandu.bsky.social
1.6K followers 7.7K following 8.8K posts
DO, BME MEng, MPH. Smarter half: @kimbeast.bsky.social He/Him. Cinema snob, ST pessimist, LT optimist. Also at @[email protected] Open Source Dev at Chromebrew, and contributor to OpenZFS + sundry other projects. Signal: satadru.01 🌩️👀 jr-q3e79ZL9H
Posts Media Videos Starter Packs
Pinned
On this anniversary of D-Day, I'm thinking again about my visit to Normandy last year.

I believe even more firmly that every American should, if able, make at least one summer pilgrimage there.

Also, several decades into this journey, I finally understand the transformative power of pilgrimages.
I finally looked up the person to whom this Tombstone belonged, the one that gave me pause when I visited the American cemetery in Normandy last summer when I saw the state I grew up in, Michigan, listed on it.

Kenneth E Bleasdell, of Ann Arbor, MI, was one of 3 brothers who died fighting in WW2.
Tombstone of Kenneth E Bleasdell, of Ann Arbor, MI, at the American Cemetery in Normandy, France, one of 3 brothers who died fighting in WW2.

https://www.honorstates.org/profiles/62470/
Meaning that the political power of a state and its Representatives + Senators to guide resources toward the people of the state is vastly higher than that of what a US Territory can do for its people.
And I maintain that the best way to stick it to colonizers is to join their polity as equals and extract reparations through subsidies.
But in a larger sense, I fundamentally think that globbing onto statehood benefits all and can reduce bigotry.

We would be less racist now against SE Asians if they had become a state, and I think a majority Puertorriqueño state would do the same here for people with Caribbean ancestry.
And yes, it's great that they finally got their independence, from Spain AND us. Also, they're HUGE, and they still benefit from the US security umbrella against China.
I'll be the first to say that Americans of that era were even more racist than now, which I'm sure was largely responsible for statehood not being offered. But the Philippines was the territorial equivalent of Hawaii. And so it should have been offered statehood instead of being left a territory.
Reposted by Satadru Pramanik
The Supreme Court’s majority right wing indicated in oral arguments that they think racism is over on the same day that the vice president defended the “I love Hitler” guy, and that the NYT reported that the current administration plans to accept only white, English-speaking refugees.
Reposted by Satadru Pramanik
Hakeem Jeffries posted pictures of two Rep. Members posing with “Young Republicans” who were part of a racist text thread (as reported by Politico).

In response, Mike Davis (well-connected in Trump World & on the Hill) called Jeffries a “house slave” for George Soros - proving Jeffries’ point.
Mike Davis racist smear
Reposted by Satadru Pramanik
tfw your 1,000-word tweets aren't working
Reposted by Satadru Pramanik
Reposted by Satadru Pramanik
"The president is illegitimate and should be removed from office" is the minimum pitch for anyone nominally opposing him
Trump is upfront in saying he will use the shutdown to punish Democrats, and here are the receipts. About $27.2 billion cut from Dem districts compared to about $0.7 billion in GOP districts.
We all complain about the media, but need this type of in-depth journalism.
www.nytimes.com/interactive/...
Trump Halts Billions in Grants for Democratic Districts During Shutdown (Gift Article)
The Trump administration has frozen or canceled nearly $28 billion primarily located in Democratic-led districts, according to an analysis by The New York Times.
www.nytimes.com
Reposted by Satadru Pramanik
Reposted by Satadru Pramanik
kavanaugh seems to be channeling bradley. “When a man has emerged from slavery, and by the aid of beneficent legislation has shaken off the inseparable concomitants of that state, there must be some stage in the progress of his elevation when he…ceases to be the special favorite of the laws.”
Justice Kavanaugh in the Callais oral argument keeps alluding to some longstanding requirement of strict scrutiny that use of race have a time limit. This is invented.
The cash transfers to subsidize states are just so insane in the US. MS gets tons of money thanks to having 2 Senators, and that's despite its relative poverty.

Much respect for Filipinos. Their two (or more) Senators for 120M would have held their own if they had become one or more states.
Yes Native Indigenous Hawaiians are on average worse off relative to white and Asian immigrants to the islands. Would that happen to PR? The GDP per capita of Hawaii is in the top quarter of US states.

The distance doesn't matter. Hawaiian Senators have insane power despite the TZ difference.
You misunderstand.

I fully believe that Filipinos are capable of self-governance, just like I believe New Yorkers are capable of self-governance, and full engagement with their national polity. I just think it should have been shared national polity.

Diversity is strength!

Distance? Hawai'i!
I'm an outsider who has only visited but has heard a little of the sordid history of what we have done to PR. It's awful!

I think a valid response to colonialism is taking up full political representation in the parent body politic to best enable reparative justice, e.g., via cash transfers.
I'm happy to grant that the statehooders may be self-serving self-interested assholes.

Having said that, I'm a selfish American who believes that giving Puertorriqueños two senators is better for the rest of us.

I also think the Philippines should have been given statehood!
Reposted by Satadru Pramanik
Tell someone this in earnest and they'll tell you why electoral politics forbids this because of lost jobs. My argument is that this logic held in 1991-2022. We need numbers and supply chain redundancy NOW. There's plenty of investments and jobs for everyone. Even for those making Soviet legacy kit.
I'm tired of saying this, but the US, Canada, Australia, New Zealand, and UK need to unify their Defense Industrial Bases or at least increase coordination to overcome the manufacturing lag with China. It's still not enough. NATO as a whole needs to do it. Callaghan explained all this in the 1970s.
Reposted by Satadru Pramanik
I'm tired of saying this, but the US, Canada, Australia, New Zealand, and UK need to unify their Defense Industrial Bases or at least increase coordination to overcome the manufacturing lag with China. It's still not enough. NATO as a whole needs to do it. Callaghan explained all this in the 1970s.
There was a person moving into our building today who was taking up most of the passenger elevator with their stuff.

They have a friend named Chandler helping them, and I had to restrain myself from making a terrible “Pivot” joke.