Diane Swonk
@dianeswonk.bsky.social
8.3K followers 360 following 1.1K posts
Chief Economist, KPMG, opinions my own
Posts Media Videos Starter Packs
dianeswonk.bsky.social
Yellen & Powell both attempted to run a “high pressure” economy to enable unemployment to drop and deliver more equal wage when inflation was too low. That is not an option at the moment, due to persistent inflation. It has been done & talked about.
dianeswonk.bsky.social
Actually, they do a lot of research on the issue. They lack the tools to do much about it but have some amazing work.
dianeswonk.bsky.social
Powell:

We do not have a view on immigration - we take it as it arrives.

The changes are larger than expected with only beginning to see the effects. Big economic factor - fewer people to work and pockets of labor shortages are emerging.

New people create supply and demand.
dianeswonk.bsky.social
Powell embraces “healthy debate” about the tensions we are facing in.

When I was an investor, I hated when everyone agreed.

Debate at moment within the Fed are some of the richest and should be healthy given we have two things happening at once - inflation & weak employment.
dianeswonk.bsky.social
State level UI estimates can add up. Generally private data seen as supplement to government data; not the main course and not enough.

Will be better when we get the whole data. Not as much data on inflation.

Fed leans in heavily on anecdotes as well. Beige book out tommorow. More color.
dianeswonk.bsky.social
$900B to Treasury, which helped offset debt and deficits. That is a misunderstood concept.

Employment concern at moment but risk on higher inflation still roughly in balance.

Transmission of lower rates blunted by ultralow rates in mortgage rates that were locked in.
dianeswonk.bsky.social
Fed will stop rolloff in balance sheet reductions in October. Powell used his humility to say Fed was slow to stop balance sheet expansion.

Need liquidity in short-term rate market and avoid a September 2019 liquidity crisis. Balance sheet has to be larger than past.

Fed has returned…
dianeswonk.bsky.social
Chair Powell receives the Adam Smith award. Data limited but outlook for employment and inflation not changed.

In person Powell emphasizes MAYBE we have seen growth pick up. Learn more dovish than his text, with rising downside risks to employment. BUT evolving outcomes - more caution next year
dianeswonk.bsky.social
Prez Anna Paulson, who rotated on to the FOMC voting committee next year, supports two additional rate cuts this year but caution next year. Worries ab employment & risk to low income households. Economy carried by affluent. BUT cautious cuts in 2026.
dianeswonk.bsky.social
Waiting for crisis is still extremely costly and means higher long term interest rates.

Zetner underscore that there is no tolerance for Fed to step in & rescue gov’t due to political pressure. There is a premium on long-term yields spikes when market sees political threats to Fed independence.
dianeswonk.bsky.social
Where will we get the political courage to deal with both sides of the revenues & expenditures.

“Liz Truss moment is dangerous thinking in that it was a positive…”counting on the @federalreserve to step in like @bankofengland not productive.
dianeswonk.bsky.social
Panel @petersonfounda1 Calthleen Kock, Karen Dynar, Ellen Zetner, Kent Smetters.

“The idea that the US is too big to fail is not true.”

Will not rule out of a Liz Trust moment.

Once things go wrong, it is too late.
dianeswonk.bsky.social
Halloween scare. Discussion of debt and deficits:

AI can’t save us - debt and deficits on unsustainable path & crisis risks rising.

Quote of day:

“We might find someone who argues we are on a sustainable path, but they would not be qualified to speak on this panel.
dianeswonk.bsky.social
Salim Ramji, CEO of Vanguard lays out the need for access to wealth accumulation for individual investors as a key equalizer. Investors do not know what they can spend & how to limit need to borrow or liquidate their 401Ks, which set them back. Leans into fixed incomes markets.
dianeswonk.bsky.social
Some economists have been arguing it for some time…such as myself. The scarring effects of the Great Recession were deep. Millennials & Gen X hit differently.
dianeswonk.bsky.social
Research in economics is rich with systemic bias and the role it plays in stoking inequality. Synergies across fields is beneficial.
dianeswonk.bsky.social
Worse yet, affluent household can buoy inflation in some goods and services even as most households push back.

Inequality complicates the Fed’s job in curbing inflation, which is in and of itself, highly corrosive.
dianeswonk.bsky.social
The outliers on consumer attitude surveys are those earning over $200K & with large stock portfolios. They are confident. We lose them, the apple cart tips.

Inflation stokes inequality and is a residual of inequality.

Wealthy households spurre post pandemic inflation. aei.org/research-produ…
https://aei.org/research-produ…
dianeswonk.bsky.social
Delays in major milestones among younger generations from marriage to homeownership and having families only exacerbated that sense.

Worse yet, the economy adds up on paper to look better than it feels to the majority of Americans. That is what we are already seeing & have been for some time.
dianeswonk.bsky.social
I think of it like traveling in traffic in a vehicle that is in the slow lane. As other vehicles pass you and the distance increases, the sensation you feel is one of being left behind even if you are moving forward.
dianeswonk.bsky.social
When the economy has more unequal income and wealth distributions a lot gets distorted.

Each generation may be making progress on average, but as the pace slows, there is a literal sense of falling behind.
dianeswonk.bsky.social
BUT, later generations are not progressing as fast as previous generations.

Inequality is nuanced and needs to be seen that way. This is a great piece on that.

minneapolisfed.org/article/2023/t…
https://minneapolisfed.org/article/2023/t…