And the original skeet referred to “right wing Jews” - not pundits. It used a pundit as an example, but it didn’t say “right wing pundit Jews”. With no further clarification, Akiva is right to point out that these are atypical positions in the right wing Jewish community.
1. Jewish right wing public figures. 2. Typical right wing Jews.
It Is certainly possible to evaluate both groups, but group 2 requires a lot more work. Akiva is clearly talking about group 2. Until now, you had not clarified you were referring to 1.
Who is “they”? You quote posted a skeet about “the Jewish right“. Akiva is saying the pundits you reference are atypical of the Jewish right. Are you saying this is the typical position of the Jewish right or are you limiting ”them” to a few right wing Jewish pundits?
