I do think this that when laymen deniers use 'saturated' they mean it in a different sense. They mean all the IR is absorbed by CO2 and none is left to absorb, based on simple ideas about absorption coefficients.
E.g. these replies on twitter
I do think this that when laymen deniers use 'saturated' they mean it in a different sense. They mean all the IR is absorbed by CO2 and none is left to absorb, based on simple ideas about absorption coefficients.
E.g. these replies on twitter
Again CO2 not saturated.
Again CO2 not saturated.
Note the dip at 650 cm-1 due to CO2 absorption, but this dip doesn't go to zero, meaning some 15 micron light escapes.
Note the dip at 650 cm-1 due to CO2 absorption, but this dip doesn't go to zero, meaning some 15 micron light escapes.
Here is the spectrum taken at 31km by balloon in 1966. The CO2 absorption at 650 cm-1 is clearly present. But radiance at 650 cm-1 is not zero. So the atmosphere is not saturated at 31 km.
Here is the spectrum taken at 31km by balloon in 1966. The CO2 absorption at 650 cm-1 is clearly present. But radiance at 650 cm-1 is not zero. So the atmosphere is not saturated at 31 km.
And one very simple observation shows it beyond doubt.
And one very simple observation shows it beyond doubt.