Michael Klapdor
@mklapdor.bsky.social
730 followers 620 following 510 posts

Social policy researcher at 🇦🇺 Parliamentary Library, Canberra Mostly welfare, social security, family payments, child care, veterans Personal account | Impersonal observations

The Parliamentary Library of Australia is a significant research and information service that supports the Parliament of Australia. Established in 1901, the library is an integral part of the Department of Parliamentary Services and provides independent, impartial and comprehensive information to members of Parliament, namely members of the Senate and House of Representatives, their staff and the broader parliamentary community. .. more

Political science 53%
Education 13%
Posts Media Videos Starter Packs
Pinned
mklapdor.bsky.social
Parliamentary Library analysis of the Social Security +Other Leg. Amdt. (Technical Changes No. 2) Bill 2025 has been published. The Bill validates historical use of income apportionment, establishes a resolution scheme and changes debt waiver provisions. parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/dow...
Screenshot of Key Points section of Bills Digest.

mklapdor.bsky.social
not sure what happened to that one - would be turned into a dashboard now

mklapdor.bsky.social
Dept of Education has been making incorrect Child Care Subsidy (CCS) entitlement decisions - says ICT system does not align with the law. Some people have been over or underpaid CCS for up to 2 weeks.
Bill will retrospectively validate previous decisions: parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/sea...
Screenshot of text from p. 7 of the Explanatory Memorandum for the Bill:
"However, the dates of effect in the CCS system for three types of decisions concerning the reconciliation of CCS entitlements do not align with the dates of effect under the Family Assistance Administration Act. As a result of the discrepancy, individuals who have failed to meet the deadlines have either been over or underpaid CCS for up to two weeks.

The retrospective amendments ensure that the relevant decisions for CCS reconciliations were validly made. The amendments waive any debts that may have arisen as a result of the misalignment. This prevents the need for recovery action to be taken against families who were overpaid. The amendments also mean that families were not underpaid as a result of the discrepancy. To mitigate any potential adverse impact on individuals, the amendments provide a mechanism for individuals to seek compensation if they can show that the retrospective amendments resulted in an acquisition of their property other than on just terms."

tom-clark.bsky.social
In one crisp para — & the 2 charts he highlights — @chrisgiles.ft.com bursts a huge number of “welfare” myths www.ft.com/content/ee67...

mklapdor.bsky.social
When you’re talking to the 18-25 demo

nobodyinpoverty.bsky.social
Wow.
"The corrected version of a Deloitte report to the Albanese government reissued by the big consulting firm after it was found to include AI-generated mistakes contains new citation errors and other flaws in referencing the academic work it relies on"

www.afr.com/politics/fed...
More errors, ‘irrelevant citations’ in Deloitte’s revised AI report
Academics question how AI-generated “gobbledegook” can be justified after the fact by irrelevant citations, as the big four firm republishes its welfare report.
www.afr.com

mklapdor.bsky.social
quote from @jeremypoxon.bsky.social: 'gotta give it to Hendo' [Ronald Henderson]
brucebradbury.bsky.social
I'll be talking about Australian poverty trends tomorrow:
Poverty trends since 1982 in Australia
peterwhiteford.bsky.social
The latest report from the ACOSS/UNSW Poverty and Inequality Partnership shows that 3.7m people are experiencing poverty. That number represents 1 in 7 people. Read the report at bit.ly/povertyoverv...
Poverty in Australia 2025: Overview – Poverty and Inequality
bit.ly

mklapdor.bsky.social
I didn’t even realise this existed til last week. But not hopeful for any vegan options
bluntshovels.bsky.social
genuinely wild ombudsman report into the NDIS participant service guarantee, including disagreeing with the agency about whether they have delivered on it, and that rules haven't been finalised since 2022! [very good plain English report too btw]

www.ombudsman.gov.au/__data/asset...
www.ombudsman.gov.au

mklapdor.bsky.social
Services Australia told Estimates last night that they will soon provide access to documents on the FOI disclosure log directly from the website (rather than having to request the doc and wait for it to be provided).
This is something I've been complaining about for years (at least since 2018)

mklapdor.bsky.social
Department of Employment and Workplace Relations before Senate Estimates today - cross portfolio/corporate on now. Employment Services scheduled for around 2pm www.youtube.com/watch?v=0WId...
Senate Education and Employment Legislation Committee [Part 1] | 09/10/2025
YouTube video by Australian Parliament House Streaming Portal
www.youtube.com

mklapdor.bsky.social
Income apportionment validation and resolution scheme Bill scheduled to be debated (and potentially passed) after question time in the House of Reps today
mklapdor.bsky.social
Parliamentary Library analysis of the Social Security +Other Leg. Amdt. (Technical Changes No. 2) Bill 2025 has been published. The Bill validates historical use of income apportionment, establishes a resolution scheme and changes debt waiver provisions. parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/dow...
Screenshot of Key Points section of Bills Digest.

mklapdor.bsky.social
Lots of social security stuff in this Bill - including changes to information sharing provisions, changes to rounding rules + indexation arrangements, and new provisions setting out how employment income is attributed when a person moves to a new payment parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/sea...

mklapdor.bsky.social
Reminder that Services Australia is now in the Finance Portfolio so will be up tonight at Senate Estimates at around 750pm in the Finance and Public Admin Committee - after the Future Fund and before the ASC (formerly Australian Submarine Corporation). Can watch here www.aph.gov.au/News_and_Eve...

mklapdor.bsky.social
The federal Minister of Social Services would need to issue legislative instrument(s) to activate the school attendance and enrolment income management measure - e.g. to declare primary and secondary school areas, determine conditions, set the % to be quarantined (currently 100%).
mklapdor.bsky.social
NT to activate school attendance income management measure. While provided for in the legislation, I don't believe it's been used previously. There were other program which could suspend or cancel payments - e.g. SEAM in the NT which ended in 2017. nit.com.au/06-10-2025/2...
NT government to refer parents of truant children to income management
The Northern Territory Government will refer parents whose children do not attend school to income management, saying the measure is part of the CLP's plan to reduce crime and strengthen community saf...
nit.com.au

mklapdor.bsky.social
As at 29/8/25 there were 32,354 on income management (IM):
- 9,938 on old IM (BasicsCard) and 22,416 on enhanced IM (SmartCard)
- 8.1% (2,649) were voluntary, the rest under compulsory measures.
- around 82% (26,450) on IM identify as Indigenous data.gov.au/data/dataset...

mklapdor.bsky.social
As at 29/8/25 there were 32,354 on income management (IM):
- 9,938 on old IM (BasicsCard) and 22,416 on enhanced IM (SmartCard)
- 8.1% (2,649) were voluntary, the rest under compulsory measures.
- around 82% (26,450) on IM identify as Indigenous data.gov.au/data/dataset...

mklapdor.bsky.social
NT to activate school attendance income management measure. While provided for in the legislation, I don't believe it's been used previously. There were other program which could suspend or cancel payments - e.g. SEAM in the NT which ended in 2017. nit.com.au/06-10-2025/2...
NT government to refer parents of truant children to income management
The Northern Territory Government will refer parents whose children do not attend school to income management, saying the measure is part of the CLP's plan to reduce crime and strengthen community saf...
nit.com.au

mklapdor.bsky.social
The income apportionment Bill is down for debate in the House of Reps this week
mklapdor.bsky.social
Parliamentary Library analysis of the Social Security +Other Leg. Amdt. (Technical Changes No. 2) Bill 2025 has been published. The Bill validates historical use of income apportionment, establishes a resolution scheme and changes debt waiver provisions. parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/dow...
Screenshot of Key Points section of Bills Digest.
maximumwelfare.bsky.social
#BREAKING 🚨 Deloitte to refund government, admits using AI in $440k report into mutual obligations issues.

Fake quotes from Federal Court case that ended Robodebt deleted from new report in Friday DEWR dump.

📰 AFR

✍️ @paulkarp.bsky.social

✍️ @edmundtadros.bsky.social

🗣️ @chrisrudge.bsky.social
HEADLINE: Deloitte to refund government, admits AI errors in $440k report Deloitte Australia will issue a partial refund to the federal government after admitting that artificial intelligence had been used in the creation of a $440,000 report littered with errors including three nonexistent academic references and a made-up quote from a Federal Court judgement.

A new version of the report for the Department of Workplace Relations (DEWR) was quietly uploaded to the department’s website on Friday, ahead of a long weekend across much of Australia. It features more than a dozen deletions of nonexistent references and footnotes, a rewritten reference list, and corrections to multiple typographic errors.

(photo of Deloitte Australia HQ) Deloitte Australia has made almost $25 million worth of deals with the Department of Workplace Relations since 2021. Photographer Dion Georgopoulos The first version of the report, about the IT system used to automate penalties in the welfare system such as pauses on the dole, was published in July. Less than a month later, Deloitte was forced to investigate the report after University of Sydney academic Dr Christopher Rudge highlighted multiple errors in the document.

At the time, Rudge speculated that the errors may have been caused by what is known as “hallucinations” by generative AI. This is where the technology responds to user queries by inventing references and quotes. Deloitte declined to comment.

The incident is embarrassing for Deloitte as it earns a growing part of its $US70.5 billion ($107 billion) in annual global revenue by providing advice and training clients and executives about AI. The firm also boasts about its widespread use of the technology within its global operations, while emphasising the need to always have humans review any output of AI. SUBHEADING: Deleted references, footnotes

The revised report has deleted a dozen references to two nonexistent reports by Professor Lisa Burton Crawford, a law professor at the University of Sydney, that were included in the first version. Two references to a nonexistent report by Professor Björn Regnell, of Lund University in Sweden, were also deleted in the new report.

Also deleted was a made up reference to a court decision in a leading robo-debt case, Deanna Amato v Commonwealth.

The new report has also deleted a reference to “Justice Davis” (a misspelling of Justice Jennifer Davies) and the made-up quote from the nonexistent paragraphs 25 and 26 in the judgement: “The burden rests on the decision-maker to be satisfied on the evidence that the debt is owed. A person’s statutory entitlements cannot lawfully be reduced based on an assumption unsupported by evidence.”